The Gaslight Anthem
The '59 Sound







Best of All-time Lists, Best of Decade Lists, etc.
Consequence of Sound (USA) - Top 100 Albums of the 2000s (2009) 93
eMusic (USA) - Top 100 Albums of the 2000s (2009) 98
Q (UK) - Top 100 Albums of the 2000s (2009) 79
Ratings
All Music Guide (USA) - Album Ratings 1-5 Stars 3.5 Stars
Robert Christgau (USA) - Consumer Guide Album Grade Dud
Metacritic (Metascore 0-100, Weighted Average of Reviews from USA and UK) 77
End of Year Lists
A.V. Club (USA) - Top Albums of 2008 13
Consequence of Sound (USA) - Top Albums of 2008 45
Eye Weekly Canadian poll (Canada) - Top Albums of 2008 19.5
Sputnikmusic (USA) - Top Albums of 2008 26
Village Voice Pazz&Jop (USA) - Top Albums of 2008 24
Classic Rock (UK) - Top Albums of 2008 13
Kerrang (UK) - Top Albums of 2008 2
NME (UK) - Top Albums of 2008 47
Q (UK) - Top Albums of 2008 20
State (Ireland) - Top Albums of 2008 24
The Guardian (UK) - Top Albums of 2008 41
Dagbladet (Norway) - Top Albums of 2008 21
Dagensskiva.com (Sweden) - Top Albums of 2008 20
Musikbyrån (Sweden) - Top Albums of 2008 34
Plan B (Norway) - Top Albums of 2008 20
Rumba (Finland) - Top Albums of 2008 8
OOR (The Netherlands) - Top Albums of 2008 41.5
Plattentests (Germany) - Top Albums of 2008 3
Visions (Germany) - Top Albums of 2008 3
RockZone (Spain) - Top Albums of 2008 49