Acclaimed Music Forums

Yes, ranked.

Interesting project!

I remember checking out a few such lists in the nineties, and there were enormous differences between lists from different countries, so I would try quite hard to find lists from all over the world. Good luck!

The Dark Side of the Moon

I don’t want everyone to be able to edit the spotify lists, and I don’t think it’s possible to make them collaborative with just a small group of people. So I’m the only one working on them (with a lot of help from posts in the ”Albums and songs recently added to Spotify” topic). I usually just upda...

I definitely agree that a lower Alexa rank could be ok for a non-English site, but #4,984,608 is much lower. There could be A LOT of sites with similar stats, maybe?

I would actually love to include this list, but also feel that consistency is necessary.....need to think more about this.

I don’t think Christgau’s list should be included. When he made the 70s and 80s lists there weren’t that many other lists around, so that’s a different story.

A few songs have no position.

The Alexa stats (#4,984,608; 36 sites linking in) are not good enough I’m afraid.

Beach House - Walk in the Park
Michael Kiwanuka - Cold Little Heart

Eligible

Updated with Treble (USA), CMT (USA), Exclaim! (Canada - Canadian songs), Revista o Grito (Brazil), Rolling Stone (Mexico), Dansende Beren (Belgium - International and national lists), Rock en Las Americas (Latin America - Latin American songs) Current top 100: 1 (1) | Robyn | Dancing On My Own | 20...

No, or hardly any, reviews.

Thanks for the clarificarion, panam.

This is a bit confusing. Why have some songs and albums been added at the end of this topic? Are there different versions of the lists?

Single critic list, isn’t it?

Any major poll among critics/musicians/artists (maybe at least 20 voters?) should probably be eligible too.

I think this is eligible, right?

Today’s song bubbles under on AM: 364. Röyksopp, featuring Robyn – The Girl and the Robot Year: 2009 Album: Junior Biggest Fan: Fred (#305) Don’t forget you can always vote for earlier songs or change your vote! Time to step in again. I didn’t put this song in my top 1000 at the time of the all-tim...

Interesting pattern that 10 out of 13 people so far have voted for one of the Beatles albums.

Today’s song bubbles under on AM: 364. Röyksopp, featuring Robyn – The Girl and the Robot Year: 2009 Album: Junior Biggest Fan: Fred (#305) Don’t forget you can always vote for earlier songs or change your vote! Time to step in again. I didn’t put this song in my top 1000 at the time of the all-tim...

1. Abbey Road by The Beatles
2. The Dark Side of the Moon by Pink Floyd

I found that I deemed this source eligible in the eoy 2011 topic. Have they made any lists between that and now?

I think this list actually is eligible. Any reason it shouldn’t be?

Sweepstakes Ron wrote: ↑
Tue Jan 07, 2020 4:31 pm
Are there any more sources we're still expecting from?

Hopefully a lot of the sources that have presented eoy lists will present eod lists now.

Mind sharing it with us the exceptions? I haven’t seen any yet! ;) Edit: A couple of years ago I decided to include eoy lists from the very popular site Gorilla vs. Bear, although they were only two staff members. What about Diario Critico and Rock en las Americas Critics Poll? What criteria are th...

Beach House - Walk in the Park
Nils Frahm - Says
Michael Kiwanuka - Cold Little Heart
Alvvays - In Undertow

Great! Thanks!

Not a surprise. It looked a little odd with ”Into You” in the top 10 and nothing else by Ariana.

Thanks!

There is no #77 (not in the article either...)

1. The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders From Mars
2. Abbey Road
3. The Dark Side of the Moon
4. pass

Honorio wrote: ↑
Mon Dec 30, 2019 10:27 am
That's great, Henry!! So you and me are doing exactly the same!
The only difference related to movies is that...

I think he actually quoted you (but lost the quote tag).

Thank you, mileswide!

International albums:
https://ng.se/artiklar/arets-utlandska-album-2019

Swedish albums:
https://ng.se/artiklar/arets-basta-svenska-skivor-2019

Hopefully someone has time to post them here. Thanks!

http://sonicmagazine.com/2019/12/23/20 ... sta-album/

Hopefully someone has time to post them here. Thanks!

1. The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders From Mars
2. OK Computer
3. Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
4. Abbey Road
5. The Dark Side of the Moon
6. Highway 61 Revisited
7. Blonde on Blonde
8. It Takes A Nation Of Millions To Hold Us Back

Andre, I am so sorry to hear about the loss of your wife. My deepest condolences. But it’s great to see your positive attitude towards the future. I hope that 2020 will be a very good year for you!

Henrik

I don’t know if there was anything wrong with the presentation, I was just lazy. Sorry for that!

Anyone else who looked at the results and just assumed you were supposed to select your favourite albums (and that the albums with the poorest scores would be eliminated)?

Btw, I selected PJ and Sufjan (my favourites).

Nick wrote: ↑
Tue Dec 24, 2019 1:41 pm
Not to be “that guy” (but I guess I’m gonna be “that guy”), but is there any chance of an update on this spreadsheet and the EOD songs spreadsheet in the near-ish future?

For the songs list, there are not many changes in the top 100, so I’m hoping another list will come in the next few days.

Sweepstakes Ron wrote: ↑
Sun Dec 22, 2019 6:56 pm
EDIT 2: Okay, actual other question: Does Latin Grammy count as a national list?

Good question. I leave it up to you. It’s your spreadsheet. For the all-time list, the method is completely different anyway.

I think this is pretty equivalent to the divide between national and foreign/international lists, i.e. the country/language of the publication and the rest.

Only national.

Sweepstakes Ron and Harold, I'm sorry for the delay, but now I finally had a look at this. I use /2 (divisions by 2) to give lower scores to national lists. And this time I planned for you to add those lists in columns GA-HA. In cells Q6-R6 and below there are /2 for the GA-HA columns, but I forgot ...

1. Pass
2. The Dark Side of the Moon
3. Highway 61 Revisited
4. London Calling
5. What's Going On
6. Pass
7. It Takes A Nation Of Millions To Hold Us Back
8. Revolver

Sorry, I'm stuck with work, so you'll have to wait another day or two...

Sorry. I’ll have a look at it tonight.

They do album reviews.The latest one was Camila's Romance. https://dbknews.com/2019/12/09/camila-cabello-romance-new-album-senorita-review/ Ok, but not 10 reviews per month. Not all critic do over 10 album reviews in a month. SPIN Magazine is on of the most respected major critics yet they barely d...

Do they have any album reviews?

From lagire:
An 2015 eoy list forgotten
viewtopic.php?f=17&t=8108

Donchano wrote: ↑
Sun Dec 15, 2019 11:45 pm

Henrik wrote: ↑
Sun Dec 15, 2019 5:17 pm
No album reviews as far as I can see, so not eligible.
They do album reviews.The latest one was Camila's Romance.

https://dbknews.com/2019/12/09/camila-c ... ta-review/

Ok, but not 10 reviews per month.

Search found 5221 matches