Acclaimed Music Forums

DDD troll account

Creation and The Creation are the same artist and should be merged.

DDD troll account

Thanks, Henrik (and his helpers), for all the work you put into this!

DDD troll account

Here's something I thought I had already posted but I couldn't find the post so here goes: The list of the Top 30 Black Sabbath songs from eclipsed appears as "The Top 30 Beatles Songs" on the individual song pages.

DDD troll account

StevieFan13 wrote:Eclipsed also includes the Beatles, right? I'm gonna include the Beatles.

The Beatles and Black Sabbath lists had already been added to the site in a previous update. They should not be included again.

DDD troll account

DDD troll account

"Tropicália ou Panis et Circencis" is ranked on AM.

Great presentation!

DDD troll account

I was wondering whether these books are already included. I couldn't find them in the critics' list section. If they are missing, I'll try to get hold of them: Die besten LP's aller Zeiten (The Best LP's of All Time; editor: Frank Laufenberg, publisher: Moewig, 1987): Google Books | Booklooker Die 1...

DDD troll account

Finished with the three lists mentioned earlier. I didn't know what to do with Fugazi's selt-titled EP so I left it off.

DDD troll account

Renaissance (the artist) was misspelled. I also changed the title of Element of Crime's 1993 album from "Weisses Papier" to "Weißes Papier" and of their 1991 album from "Damals hinterm mond" to "Damals hinterm Mond" Jorge Ben's "África Brasil" was gi...

DDD troll account

How recently? For instance, what about the lists marked green in this thread. Which of them are still waiting to be added? And what about the ones not marked green yet. Are they eligible?

DDD troll account

- published in German Rolling Stone 11/2008 - compiled by jurors such as Paul Weller, Jarvis Cocker and Nick Mason - Link on poplist.de: http://www.poplist.de/poplist.php?category=PinkFloyd:Die30bestenSongs#list 1. Shine On You Crazy Diamond 2. See Emily Play 3. Interstellar Overdrive 4. Arnold Layn...

DDD troll account

Two more on Poplist from German country magazine Rookie: * Die 50 besten Americana-Platten aller Zeiten (The 50 Best Americana Records of All Time; published in Rookie September 2012) * Die 50 besten Folkrock-Alben aller Zeiten (The Best Folk Rock Records of All Time; published in Rookie May 2013)

DDD troll account

Published in German Rolling Stone 09/2009: 1. A Day in the Life 2. Strawberry Fields Forever 3. Eleanor Rigby 4. Penny Lane 5. Help! 6. Happiness Is a Warm Gun 7. Helter Skelter 8. Hey Jude 9. Across the Universe 10. I Am the Walrus 11. Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown) 12. Something 13. Nowhere ...

DDD troll account

Here's the one list on poplist.de that may (or may not) apply to this:
The 100 Best Political Songs.

DDD troll account

Would you consider these EOY lists?

DDD troll account

And now with the nominations (winner in bold): 2016: Radiohead - A Moon Shaped Pool Solange - A Seat at the Table Kate Tempest - Let Them Eat Chaos A Tribe Called Quest - We Got It from Here... Thank You 4 Your Service 2015: Benjamin Clementine - At Least for Now Grimes - Art Angels Kendrick Lamar -...

DDD troll account

The following are on Poplist : Musikexpress: The 33⅓ Best Punk Albums The 33⅓ Best Hip Hop Albums The 25 Best Garage Rock Revival Albums The 25 Best Garage Rock Albums The 50 Best Unknown Electronic Albums The 30 Best Psychedelic Albums The 25 Best Horror Film Soundtracks German Rolling Stone: The 5...

DDD troll account

Couldn't find this here so; what about the Soundcheck Award? It's selected from those albums that received a "hit" rating from four critics in the weekly radioeins show Soundcheck . A list of four nominees is selected from those by forty critics and other people working in the music indust...

DDD troll account

There's also a whole bunch here of course.

DDD troll account

Here's the album list: 13th Floor Elevators - Easter Everywhere [2] The 13th Floor Elevators - The Psychedelic Sounds of the 13th Floor Elevators [2] 22-Pistepirkko - Big Lupu 22 Pistepirkko - Rumble City, LaLa Land David Ackles - American Gothic David Ackles - David Ackles David Ackles - Subway to ...

DDD troll account

I'm already working on the albums list.

DDD troll account

Henrik, I'm finished with the Singles list. Below are all the songs in alphabetical order by artist. The number in the brackets is the number of appearances on individual lists. I tried to correct typos etc. whenever I found them but I probably missed a few. If you want me to change anything about t...

DDD troll account

Henrik wrote:Could someone help me create such a list?

I'll be without Internet access over the weekend. I could do it afterwards but if anyone else wants to, feel free.

EDIT: Just began working on this but it'll take some time.

DDD troll account

There's actually two more lists from Hartbeat! that were done in a similar manner and that have only been added fairly recently to Poplist: greatest albums and greatest b-sides of all time. While Hartbeat! itself probably was relevant enough a publication, I'm not sure whether the lists are eligible...

DDD troll account

Seems to be a 2016 list and not the same as the 1997 version by the same publication. Online you can find the countdown here, here and here. Also on Poplist.

DDD troll account

It's possible that some critics' lists take influence into account and Blue Lines definitely has an advantage there. So, in terms of overall (objective) importance BL would indeed rank higher even if Mezzanine makes up for that in (subjective) quality.

DDD troll account

Note, by the way, that the song lists may contain oversights on behalf of the eclipsed staff. For instance, "No More Mr. Nice Guy" received a perfect track rating, yet isn't included in Cooper's top 30 although the bottom twelve on the list failed to get a perfect rating. But I guess that'...

DDD troll account

You're very welcome!

DDD troll account

OK, this should be all the lists in the two books: Live albums are not part of the album rankings. Nevertheless live and compilation albums are also placed in one of the categories and presented on the artists' pages. Some of them have their own entry that corresponds to those of the studio albums, ...

DDD troll account

I've got the books now. Is there a special format you'd like me to post the lists in or is the way I did it for The Beatles and Sabbath fine?

DDD troll account

I was busy this semester and didn't manage to turn in a list. So Henry may be lucky since this will hurt Waits.

DDD troll account

A library close to where I live has both books. I'll try to get hold of them.

DDD troll account

Henrik, the Black Sabbath list from this book is shown on the song pages as "The Top 30 Beatles Songs".

DDD troll account

It would be nice if these lists were eligible. Crotics are often (but not always) wannabe musicians after all. :mrgreen: Costello's list was deemed eligible a while ago and is included on the site. I don't remember Henrik's reasoning exactly but I think it had something to do with Costello's expert...

DDD troll account

I assume this is ineligible but it hasn't been posted yet and Henrik should decide: Link This is a chronological, not a ranked list. 1. Psycho - Bernard Herrmann 2. Kwaidan - Toru Takemitsu 3. Rosemary's Baby - Krzysztof Komeda 4. Vampyros Lesbos - Manfred Hübler, Siegfried Schwab & Jesús Franco...

DDD troll account

All-time lists etc., that were added last year or are in JR's, Pierre's or pauldrach's summary threads (the sticky threads in the "Critics lists" forum): It would also help me immensely if you could help me get these lists into one spreadsheet. I will create a template for this. Hopefully...

DDD troll account

I assume these are ineligible: * Best Punk Albums according to Musikexpress * Best Hip-Hop Albums according to Musikexpress * Best Contemporary Garage Rock Albums according to Musikexpress * Best Early Garage Rock Albums according to Musikexpress * Best Unknown Electronic Albums according to Musike...

DDD troll account

Updated this to include new lists and exclude the ones that have been added in the last update.

DDD troll account

Thanks for all the work, Henrik. I wish you all the best!

DDD troll account

Here are the links to the first and second book on the eclipsed website. You can look into the second one here . Apparently, the books also rank the artists' albums and place them in one of five categories (which I'd say roughly correspond to TSPDT's categories for films): Kaufrausch (highly recomme...

DDD troll account

Yeah, sounds good. I'd add it to the summary of German-language lists but does anybody even have access to the actual lists?

DDD troll account

There's actually two books: Part 1 and Part 2 . Each of them was compiled by journalists of eclipsed and analyses the complete discographies of 20 rock artists, including top 30 song lists for each artist. The artists examined in part 1 are Pink Floyd, David Bowie, Genesis, Jethro Tull, The Doors, J...

DDD troll account

The Wikipedia article on the Western canon might be interesting for your purposes. The "Examples" section includes a number of lists I feel could be included though many probably don't meet the requirements. What's your take on University reading lists?

DDD troll account

The one movie I hadn't seen in the top 100 (The Mother and the Whore) fell off, only to be replaced by another movie I haven't had a chance to see (A Brighter Summer Day). Why can't I find these in good condition anywhere? Why can't I live near one of those big cities that every once in a while get...

DDD troll account

You're welcome, Henrik! JR, I've been wondering that, too. A few others such as "Lady in Satin" or "In the Wee Small Hours" also seem quite weird in that regard. I assume he wanted to have albums from diverse eras and genres and just wasn't as well-versed in some areas, thus havi...

DDD troll account

And done! They're all in the first post now.

DDD troll account

I could do that if you told me what you mean by transcribe.

DDD troll account

Federico wrote:And we definitely have 5 clashes: Farmer in the City, Jumpin Jack Flash, Starman, Sea Song and Don't want to know if you are lonely. In the book they claim to have 7 clashes.

Townes Van Zandt's "Kathleen" is another one.

DDD troll account

Here's my letterboxd account btw if anyone's interested: http://letterboxd.com/pauldrach/

DDD troll account

Any other sites you recommend then? This may not be precisely what you're looking for but the DDD forums have a handful of very knowledgeable and intelligent film buffs and from time to time in-depth discussions of auteurs or certain films do happen there. Also, there's always some list projects go...

Search found 253 matches