Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
We're getting closer with each decade.
Closer (1980) tracklisting:
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
02 | Isolation
03 | Passover
04 | Colony
05 | A Means to an End
06 | Heart and Soul
07 | Twenty Four Hours
08 | The Eternal
09 | Decades
Grace will be shining next week. Hallelujah!
Closer (1980) tracklisting:
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
02 | Isolation
03 | Passover
04 | Colony
05 | A Means to an End
06 | Heart and Soul
07 | Twenty Four Hours
08 | The Eternal
09 | Decades
Grace will be shining next week. Hallelujah!
- Honorio
- Higher Ground
- Posts: 4528
- Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2012 7:38 am
- Location: L'Eliana, Valencia, Spain
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
02 | Isolation
06 | Heart and Soul
08 | The Eternal
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
09 | Decades
07 | Twenty Four Hours
03 | Passover
05 | A Means to an End
04 | Colony
06 | Heart and Soul
08 | The Eternal
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
09 | Decades
07 | Twenty Four Hours
03 | Passover
05 | A Means to an End
04 | Colony
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
Atrocity Exhibition
Colony
Isolation
The Eternal
Twenty Four Hours
Heart and Soul
Decades
A Means to an End
Passover
I'm very curious to see how these end up ranking, since not one of the nine is AM ranked (which is criminal).
Colony
Isolation
The Eternal
Twenty Four Hours
Heart and Soul
Decades
A Means to an End
Passover
I'm very curious to see how these end up ranking, since not one of the nine is AM ranked (which is criminal).
-
- Strange Fruit
- Posts: 65
- Joined: Sat Nov 21, 2015 1:14 am
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
09 | Decades
07 | Twenty Four Hours
08 | The Eternal
02 | Isolation
05 | A Means to an End
06 | Heart and Soul
04 | Colony
03 | Passover
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
07 | Twenty Four Hours
08 | The Eternal
02 | Isolation
05 | A Means to an End
06 | Heart and Soul
04 | Colony
03 | Passover
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
09 | Decades
07 | Twenty Four Hours
08 | The Eternal
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
02 | Isolation
06 | Heart and Soul
05 | A Means to an End
03 | Passover
04 | Colony
07 | Twenty Four Hours
08 | The Eternal
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
02 | Isolation
06 | Heart and Soul
05 | A Means to an End
03 | Passover
04 | Colony
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
Decades
The Eternal
Twenty Four Hours
Colony
Heart and Soul
Isolation
Passover
A Means to an End
Atrocity Exhibition
Really weird how all the best songs are at the end.
The Eternal
Twenty Four Hours
Colony
Heart and Soul
Isolation
Passover
A Means to an End
Atrocity Exhibition
Really weird how all the best songs are at the end.
" Ah, yes! Our meager restitution"
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
Heart and Soul: 9
Isolation: 9
Decades: 8.5
The Eternal: 8
Passover: 7.5
A Means to an End: 7.5
Colony: 7
Twenty Four Hours: 7
Atrocity Exhibition: 6
Isolation: 9
Decades: 8.5
The Eternal: 8
Passover: 7.5
A Means to an End: 7.5
Colony: 7
Twenty Four Hours: 7
Atrocity Exhibition: 6
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
Twenty Four Hours
Decades
A Means to an End
The Eternal
Isolation
Atrocity Exhibition
Heart and Soul
Passover
Colony
Decades
A Means to an End
The Eternal
Isolation
Atrocity Exhibition
Heart and Soul
Passover
Colony
- Live in Phoenix
- Full of Fire
- Posts: 2510
- Joined: Wed Jan 02, 2013 12:50 am
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
Personal top 10.
01 | Decades
02 | Twenty Four Hours
03 | The Eternal
04 | Colony
05 | Isolation
06 | A Means to an End
07 | Passover
08 | Atrocity Exhibition
09 | Heart and Soul
01 | Decades
02 | Twenty Four Hours
03 | The Eternal
04 | Colony
05 | Isolation
06 | A Means to an End
07 | Passover
08 | Atrocity Exhibition
09 | Heart and Soul
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
I largely prefer Unkwown Pleasure but this is nonetheless very enjoyable.
Great:
08 | The Eternal
03 | Passover
Good:
09 | Decades
04 | Colony
07 | Twenty Four Hours
02 | Isolation
OK:
05 | A Means to an End
06 | Heart and Soul
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
Great:
08 | The Eternal
03 | Passover
Good:
09 | Decades
04 | Colony
07 | Twenty Four Hours
02 | Isolation
OK:
05 | A Means to an End
06 | Heart and Soul
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
09 | Decades*
08 | The Eternal*
07 | Twenty Four Hours*
03 | Passover
02 | Isolation
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
05 | A Means to an End
06 | Heart and Soul
04 | Colony
Personal favorites*
Overall album rating: 8.44
08 | The Eternal*
07 | Twenty Four Hours*
03 | Passover
02 | Isolation
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
05 | A Means to an End
06 | Heart and Soul
04 | Colony
Personal favorites*
Overall album rating: 8.44
- ordinaryperson
- Movin' On Up
- Posts: 931
- Joined: Sun Dec 28, 2014 1:23 am
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
"Behind his eyes he says, 'I still exist.'"
01 | Isolation
02 | Atrocity Exhibition
03 | Twenty Four Hours
04 | Colony
05 | The Eternal
06 | Decades
07 | A Means to an End
08 | Heart and Soul
09 | Passover
01 | Isolation
02 | Atrocity Exhibition
03 | Twenty Four Hours
04 | Colony
05 | The Eternal
06 | Decades
07 | A Means to an End
08 | Heart and Soul
09 | Passover
There is No More Firmament.
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
1. Twenty four hours
2. Isolation
3. A means to an end
4. Atrocity exhibition
5. Colony
6. Heart and soul
7. Decades
8. Passover
9. The Eternal
2. Isolation
3. A means to an end
4. Atrocity exhibition
5. Colony
6. Heart and soul
7. Decades
8. Passover
9. The Eternal
- bonnielaurel
- Keep On Movin'
- Posts: 1665
- Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2013 2:48 pm
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
02 | Isolation
07 | Twenty Four Hours
03 | Passover
09 | Decades
05 | A Means to an End
08 | The Eternal
04 | Colony
06 | Heart and Soul
02 | Isolation
07 | Twenty Four Hours
03 | Passover
09 | Decades
05 | A Means to an End
08 | The Eternal
04 | Colony
06 | Heart and Soul
De gustibus et coloribus non est disputandum.
-
- Different Class
- Posts: 307
- Joined: Sat Aug 04, 2018 3:58 am
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
1) A Means To An End
2) Atrocity Exhibition
3) Twenty Four Hours
4) Heart and Soul
5) The Eternal
6) Isolation
7) Decades
8) Colony
9) Passover
2) Atrocity Exhibition
3) Twenty Four Hours
4) Heart and Soul
5) The Eternal
6) Isolation
7) Decades
8) Colony
9) Passover
-
- Movin' On Up
- Posts: 978
- Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 7:47 pm
- Location: Hoboken, Antwerp, Belgium
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
06 | Heart and Soul
07 | Twenty Four Hours
02 | Isolation
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
09 | Decades
05 | A Means to an End
03 | Passover
08 | The Eternal
04 | Colony
07 | Twenty Four Hours
02 | Isolation
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
09 | Decades
05 | A Means to an End
03 | Passover
08 | The Eternal
04 | Colony
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
9 Decades
7 Twenty Four Hours
2 Isolation
5 A Mean to an End
4 Colony
6 Heart and Soul
8 The Eternal
1 Atrocity Exhibition
3 Passover
7 Twenty Four Hours
2 Isolation
5 A Mean to an End
4 Colony
6 Heart and Soul
8 The Eternal
1 Atrocity Exhibition
3 Passover
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
02 | Isolation
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
09 | Decades
07 | Twenty Four Hours
08 | The Eternal
06 | Heart and Soul
03 | Passover
05 | A Means to an End
04 | Colony
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
09 | Decades
07 | Twenty Four Hours
08 | The Eternal
06 | Heart and Soul
03 | Passover
05 | A Means to an End
04 | Colony
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
02| Isolation
07| Twenty Four Hours
06| Heart and Soul
04| Colony
09| Decades
01| Atrocity Exhibition
05| A Means To An End
03| Passover
08| The Eternal
07| Twenty Four Hours
06| Heart and Soul
04| Colony
09| Decades
01| Atrocity Exhibition
05| A Means To An End
03| Passover
08| The Eternal
All I got inside is vacancy!
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
09 | Decades
06 | Heart and Soul
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
05 | A Means to an End
07 | Twenty Four Hours
02 | Isolation
04 | Colony
03 | Passover
08 | The Eternal
06 | Heart and Soul
01 | Atrocity Exhibition
05 | A Means to an End
07 | Twenty Four Hours
02 | Isolation
04 | Colony
03 | Passover
08 | The Eternal
Re: Rank the Tracks: Joy Division's Closer (1980)
Hello,
I like Joy Division. They made quite good stuff, but I don’t really understand why they are so praised.
Probably the love they receive is bigger due to the tragic end of Ian Curtis, or maybe it’s just because their music is greater than I feel when I listen to them.
For me New Order are ten thousand times better, but unfortunately less acclaimed.
In any case, Closer is a great record and the first four on my ranking are wonderful songs.
1- 09 | Decades
2- 07 | Twenty Four Hours
3- 02 | Isolation
4- 01 | Atrocity Exhibition
5- 05 | A Means to an End
6- 06 | Heart and Soul
7- 08 | The Eternal
8- 04 | Colony
9- 03 | Passover
Best regards,
I like Joy Division. They made quite good stuff, but I don’t really understand why they are so praised.
Probably the love they receive is bigger due to the tragic end of Ian Curtis, or maybe it’s just because their music is greater than I feel when I listen to them.
For me New Order are ten thousand times better, but unfortunately less acclaimed.
In any case, Closer is a great record and the first four on my ranking are wonderful songs.
1- 09 | Decades
2- 07 | Twenty Four Hours
3- 02 | Isolation
4- 01 | Atrocity Exhibition
5- 05 | A Means to an End
6- 06 | Heart and Soul
7- 08 | The Eternal
8- 04 | Colony
9- 03 | Passover
Best regards,