| Best of All-time Lists, Best of Decade Lists, etc. | |
| Popdose (USA) - Top 100 Albums of the 2000s (2009) | 57 |
| Ratings | |
| All Music Guide (USA) - Album Ratings 1-5 Stars | 4 Stars |
| Robert Christgau (USA) - Consumer Guide Album Grade | Choice Cut |
| Metacritic (Metascore 0-100, Weighted Average of Reviews from USA and UK) | 72 |
| End of Year Lists | |
| Billboard (USA) - Albums of the Year | 8 |
| Blender (USA) - Albums of the Year | 23 |
| Grammy Awards (USA) - Album of the Year | Winner |
| Idolator (USA) - Albums of the Year (Jackin' Pop Poll) | 35 |
| PopMatters (USA) - Albums of the Year | 13 |
| Rolling Stone (USA) - Albums of the Year | 19 |
| Village Voice (USA) - Albums of the Year | 20 |
| Entertainment Weekly (USA) - Albums of the Year | 6 |