Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
- spiritualized
- Full of Fire
- Posts: 2848
- Joined: Mon Dec 24, 2012 4:45 pm
- Location: Near Montpellier, France
Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
Hello to all, thanks for your participation in the first round !
For this second round, we'll do an "unacclaimed songs" style of competing with the songs pitted against each other in groups of four.
Rank the songs by order of preference.
The first one will get 4 points, second 3, third 2 and last one 1
The second group having 5 contenders, we'll move to 5 points for the top song, etc...
The groups have been seeded by AM rank. You should base your rankings on the quality of the cover.
If I've made a mistake, don't hesitate to shout ! Votes will close next Monday @ 12:00 European Time
STIMPY Group
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
Get Here - Oleta Adams
FIGARO Group
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
Happy voting !
For this second round, we'll do an "unacclaimed songs" style of competing with the songs pitted against each other in groups of four.
Rank the songs by order of preference.
The first one will get 4 points, second 3, third 2 and last one 1
The second group having 5 contenders, we'll move to 5 points for the top song, etc...
The groups have been seeded by AM rank. You should base your rankings on the quality of the cover.
If I've made a mistake, don't hesitate to shout ! Votes will close next Monday @ 12:00 European Time
STIMPY Group
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
Get Here - Oleta Adams
FIGARO Group
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
Happy voting !
Last edited by spiritualized on Wed May 11, 2022 5:31 am, edited 1 time in total.
- spiritualized
- Full of Fire
- Posts: 2848
- Joined: Mon Dec 24, 2012 4:45 pm
- Location: Near Montpellier, France
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
PS - The Wedding Present were really the Ukrainians in this song - Kudos and they should be voted first !!!
- bonnielaurel
- Keep On Movin'
- Posts: 1665
- Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2013 2:48 pm
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
These groups still have two artists for each song. Shouldn't that be reduced to one?
De gustibus et coloribus non est disputandum.
- spiritualized
- Full of Fire
- Posts: 2848
- Joined: Mon Dec 24, 2012 4:45 pm
- Location: Near Montpellier, France
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
Sorry ! Fixedbonnielaurel wrote: ↑Tue May 10, 2022 8:23 pm These groups still have two artists for each song. Shouldn't that be reduced to one?
- bonnielaurel
- Keep On Movin'
- Posts: 1665
- Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2013 2:48 pm
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
So here they are:
STIMPY Group
Get Here - Oleta Adams
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
FIGARO Group
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
The second group is very strong.
STIMPY Group
Get Here - Oleta Adams
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
FIGARO Group
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
The second group is very strong.
De gustibus et coloribus non est disputandum.
- Honorio
- Higher Ground
- Posts: 4527
- Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2012 7:38 am
- Location: L'Eliana, Valencia, Spain
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
4. The Wedding Present - Вася – васильок (1989)
6. The Fall - Mr Pharmacist (1986)
7. Oleta Adams - Get Here (1990)
9. Scott Bradlee & Postmodern Jukebox - Steal My Girl (2015)
1. Phoebe Bridgers - You Missed My Heart (2017)
2. Fiona Apple - Why Try To Change Me Now (2009)
3. June Tabor - Beat the Retreat (1994)
5. Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra - When You're Smiling (The Whole World Smiles With You) (1929)
8. Whitney Houston with Cissy Houston - I Know Him So Well (1987)
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
STIMPY
1st: Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
2. Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
3. Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
4. Get Here - Oleta Adams
FIGARO
1st: You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
2. When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
3. Why Try To Change Me Now? - Fiona Apple
4. I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
5. Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
1st: Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
2. Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
3. Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
4. Get Here - Oleta Adams
FIGARO
1st: You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
2. When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
3. Why Try To Change Me Now? - Fiona Apple
4. I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
5. Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
REN GROUP
1 | The Wedding Present | Vasia Vasylok
2 | The Fall | Mr. Pharmacist
6 | Oleta Adams | Get Here
9 | Scott Bradlee's Postmodern Jukebox | Steal My Girl
PINOCCHIO GROUP
3 | June Tabor | Beat the Retreat
4 | Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929 | When You're Smiling
5 | Phoebe Bridgers | You Missed My Heart
7 | Fiona Apple | Why Try to Change Me Now?
8 | Whitney & Cissy Houston | I Know Him So Well
1 | The Wedding Present | Vasia Vasylok
2 | The Fall | Mr. Pharmacist
6 | Oleta Adams | Get Here
9 | Scott Bradlee's Postmodern Jukebox | Steal My Girl
PINOCCHIO GROUP
3 | June Tabor | Beat the Retreat
4 | Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929 | When You're Smiling
5 | Phoebe Bridgers | You Missed My Heart
7 | Fiona Apple | Why Try to Change Me Now?
8 | Whitney & Cissy Houston | I Know Him So Well
All I got inside is vacancy!
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
STIMPY Group
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
Get Here - Oleta Adams
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
FIGARO Group
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
Get Here - Oleta Adams
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
FIGARO Group
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
- Schüttelbirne
- Into the Groove
- Posts: 2382
- Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2019 9:50 am
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
STIMPY Group
1 | Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
5 | Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
7 | Get Here - Oleta Adams
8 | Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
FIGARO Group
2 | When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
3 | You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
4 | Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
6 | Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
9 | I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
1 | Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
5 | Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
7 | Get Here - Oleta Adams
8 | Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
FIGARO Group
2 | When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
3 | You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
4 | Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
6 | Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
9 | I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
STIMPY Group
1 | Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present / Ukranians
7 | Get Here - Oleta Adams
8 | Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
9 | Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
FIGARO Group
2 | You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
3 | Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
4 | Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
5 | I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
6 | When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
1 | Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present / Ukranians
7 | Get Here - Oleta Adams
8 | Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
9 | Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
FIGARO Group
2 | You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
3 | Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
4 | Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
5 | I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
6 | When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
STIMPY Group
1. Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
2. Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
3. Get Here - Oleta Adams
4. Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
FIGARO Group
1. Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
2. Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
3. When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
4. You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
5. I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
1. Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
2. Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
3. Get Here - Oleta Adams
4. Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
FIGARO Group
1. Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
2. Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
3. When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
4. You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
5. I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
- Rob
- Die Mensch Maschine
- Posts: 7420
- Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2012 3:53 pm
- Location: Nijmegen, The Netherlands
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
STIMPY Group
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
Get Here - Oleta Adams
FIGARO Group
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
Get Here - Oleta Adams
FIGARO Group
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
STIMPY Group
Get Here - Oleta Adams
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
FIGARO Group
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
Get Here - Oleta Adams
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
FIGARO Group
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
STIMPY Group
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
Get Here - Oleta Adams
FIGARO Group
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
Get Here - Oleta Adams
FIGARO Group
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
STIMPY Group
Get Here - Oleta Adams
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
FIGARO Group
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
Get Here - Oleta Adams
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
FIGARO Group
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
- spiritualized
- Full of Fire
- Posts: 2848
- Joined: Mon Dec 24, 2012 4:45 pm
- Location: Near Montpellier, France
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
STIMPY Group
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
Get Here - Oleta Adams
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
FIGARO Group
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present
Get Here - Oleta Adams
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox
FIGARO Group
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor
- spiritualized
- Full of Fire
- Posts: 2848
- Joined: Mon Dec 24, 2012 4:45 pm
- Location: Near Montpellier, France
Re: Cover Versions vs Originals - Phase 2.7
Results !
STIMPY Group
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present (39)
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall (38)
Get Here - Oleta Adams (30)
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox (23)
FIGARO Group
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers (50)
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple (43)
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929 (40)
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor (37)
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston (25)
Repêchage
1. Janis Joplin - Me & Bobby McGee (49)
2. Doin' Time - Lana Del Rey (49)
3. Soft Cell - Tainted Love (48)
4. Aretha Franklin - Respect (47)
STIMPY Group
Vasia Vasylok - The Wedding Present (39)
Mr Pharmacist - The Fall (38)
Get Here - Oleta Adams (30)
Steal My Girl - Postmodern Jukebox (23)
FIGARO Group
You Missed My Heart - Phoebe Bridgers (50)
Why Try To Change Me Now ? - Fiona Apple (43)
When You're Smiling - Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra 1929 (40)
Beat the Retreat - June Tabor (37)
I Know Him So Well - Whitney & Cissy Houston (25)
Repêchage
1. Janis Joplin - Me & Bobby McGee (49)
2. Doin' Time - Lana Del Rey (49)
3. Soft Cell - Tainted Love (48)
4. Aretha Franklin - Respect (47)